Outgrowing QuickBooks

Still running manufacturing on QuickBooks? It's great at the books, and that's about where it stops.

Almost every small manufacturer starts on QuickBooks, and for good reason, since it's cheap, everybody knows it and you can be up and running in an afternoon. The trouble starts the day the business needs to be more than books, because QuickBooks was built to invoice and pay bills, not to track inventory, build product or run a shop floor.

Video demo of Odoo accounting for manufacturers moving off QuickBooks A 5 minute harbor cruise through Odoo accounting.

Can QuickBooks handle manufacturing? Not really.

The problem is that it never fails all at once. You don't hit a wall with QuickBooks, you build one a brick at a time, and each fix feels small enough on its own that nobody stops to add them up.

01

A spreadsheet for inventory

QuickBooks can count items on a shelf, but it can't tell you what's tied up in raw material, what's on the floor and what's ready to ship.

02

Another tool for work orders

There's nowhere in QuickBooks to put a bill of materials or a work order, so production ends up living in a separate app or on a whiteboard.

03

Somebody reconciling it all

Now 3 systems hold 3 versions of the truth, and someone spends part of every week keying numbers from one into the other and hoping they agree.

04

A separate file per company

Add a second plant or a second entity and you're running separate QuickBooks files and rolling them up by hand at month end.

None of it looks like a crisis until you're running a $5 million manufacturing business on a system that was built for a 2 person consulting shop, and we've sat with manufacturers at that size who were still trying to run production out of QuickBooks. It wasn't a minor inconvenience for them, it was falling apart. If you're not sure whether you need an ERP or just an MRP, ERP vs MRP vs MES sorts out the acronyms, and the best ERP for a small manufacturer covers what shops under $10M should look at.

2 ways off QuickBooks, and we'll tell you which one we lean toward

Manufacturers who outgrow QuickBooks tend to go one of 2 ways. Neither one is wrong, and it mostly comes down to how attached you are to the books you already trust versus how much reconciling you're willing to keep doing every week.

Path 1

Keep QuickBooks, bolt on a manufacturing app

Accounting stays where it is, and a separate inventory and production tool syncs to it. Katana is a common pick for this.

  • Less change for the accounting side
  • 2 subscriptions and a sync to babysit
  • Every new need is another app to connect
Path 2

Move to one connected system

Quoting, inventory, manufacturing, purchasing and accounting all run on one database, which is how Odoo is built.

  • One set of numbers, nothing to reconcile
  • Lot tracking and work orders come in the box
  • A bigger move up front, and a cleaner one

We lean toward path 2 and we say so, because after more than 400 ERP integrations over 22 years we've seen how often the bolt-on approach turns back into the same pile of workarounds it was supposed to fix. If you're weighing path 1, read our Katana and Odoo comparison first, and Odoo Pricing Explained covers what path 2 costs in real numbers.

You're not giving up the accounting

This is usually the real hesitation, so it's worth saying plainly. Moving off QuickBooks doesn't mean losing the accounting you rely on, and on a few things the accounting side gets better, which surprises people. We also have a CPA on staff who handles the accounting side of every project.

What you keep

Everything you use today

Bank reconciliation, financial statements, payables, receivables and electronic 1099 filing are all still there, so your bookkeeper isn't starting over.

What gets better

Invoices that match themselves

A vendor invoice comes in, gets read automatically and gets matched against the purchase order and the receipt without anyone keying in numbers. That's a real gap in QuickBooks that has nothing to do with production.

What you finally get

The manufacturing side

Bills of materials, work orders, real inventory with lot tracking and more than one company in the same system, all posting straight to the books.

You can see the full feature list on Odoo's accounting page, or watch the 5 minute demo up top.

Quick answers about leaving QuickBooks

Can QuickBooks handle manufacturing?

Not well. QuickBooks handles the accounting side fine, but it has no real bills of materials, work orders or production tracking, so manufacturers end up running inventory and production in spreadsheets or separate apps and reconciling them by hand.

When should a manufacturer move off QuickBooks?

When the workarounds start costing more than the system. If someone is reconciling spreadsheets every week, you can't trust your inventory numbers, or you've added a second plant or entity, you've outgrown it.

Can I keep QuickBooks and add a manufacturing app?

Yes, and some shops do it with tools like Katana. The tradeoff is 2 systems and a sync between them, and as the business grows that sync tends to become one more thing to manage.

Will I lose accounting features if I move to Odoo?

No. Bank reconciliation, financial statements and electronic 1099 filing are all there, and Odoo adds things QuickBooks doesn't do, like reading vendor invoices automatically and matching them to the purchase order and receipt.

What does Odoo cost compared to QuickBooks?

More than QuickBooks, and it does a lot more. Odoo lists at about $41 per user per month, closer to $61 per user once you're on Odoo.sh, plus hosting and data storage, and implementation usually costs more than the licenses.

Is BlackIron biased toward Odoo?

Yes, and we say so. We think one connected system fits most small and mid-size manufacturers better than QuickBooks plus add-ons, but we'll tell you if your shop is the exception.

See where QuickBooks is making you compromise

If you're running a shop floor on QuickBooks, you've probably built a workaround for every gap it leaves. Take 90 seconds and see exactly which compromises you're making and how Odoo closes each one, and if you'd rather talk it through, a principal of BlackIron is glad to.

We won't call you, we swear! (We may email you though.)

Still looking around?

10 more free guides like this one

Comparisons, real pricing and short videos for every stage of an ERP evaluation, with no forms to fill out.

See all the free tools